Legal

Hidden defects in a purchase: expert in Barcelona and the Civil Code of Catalonia

You bought a home in Catalonia and a serious defect that was not visible has appeared. What the Civil Code of Catalonia regulates, which deadlines appear in its text and what evidence the hidden defects expert provides.

Two-storey house with a porch and balcony, surrounded by trees and a fence.

Hidden defects expert in Barcelona: when you need one

If you bought a home in Barcelona or elsewhere in Catalonia and a serious defect appears that was not visible at purchase, the hidden defects expert inspects the property, documents the defect and issues an expert report evidencing what the defect is, how serious it is and whether it already existed when the property was sold. This guide is technical and general information, not legal advice: your lawyer must confirm which rules and deadlines apply to you.

Which law governs a purchase in Catalonia

Where Catalan civil law applies, a sale is regulated by Book Six of the Civil Code of Catalonia (Law 3/2017, consolidated text in the BOE, in Spanish). This law does not speak of «hidden defects» but of lack of conformity of the goods with the contract. According to its consolidated text:

  • The seller is liable for a lack of conformity that exists at delivery and becomes apparent within the following three years (art. 621-23.1).
  • A lack of conformity that appears within two years of delivery is presumed to have existed at that time, unless this is incompatible with the nature of the goods or of the defect (art. 621-24.1).
  • The buyer must notify and describe the defect to the seller without undue delay (art. 621-29.1). Failing to do so does not forfeit the right to invoke it, but the buyer is liable for damage caused by the delay (art. 621-29.2).
  • The buyer's remedies include demanding performance (including repair or replacement), withholding payment, terminating the contract, reducing the price and claiming damages, which can be combined where not incompatible (art. 621-37).
  • The buyer's claims and actions lapse after three years, counted from when the buyer knows or can know of the lack of conformity (art. 621-44).

If the purchase were governed by the Spanish state Civil Code

The Civil Code (in Spanish) obliges the seller to answer for hidden defects that make the item unfit for its use or reduce that use so much that the buyer would not have bought it or would have paid less (art. 1484), and provides that the actions lapse six months after delivery of the item sold (art. 1490). The difference from the Catalan deadline is large, which is why you should check with a lawyer which rules apply to your purchase.

Common examples of defects that are assessed

  • Serious structural problems (cracks hidden by finishes)
  • Persistent damp from capillary action or leaks
  • Foundation defects (differential settlement)
  • Hidden defective installations (plumbing, electrics)
  • Aluminosis or reinforcement corrosion

The role of the expert report

In practice, the claimant must prove the defect, and the expert report makes it possible to:

  1. Show that the defect existed at delivery, by analysing the degree of development of the pathology.
  2. Evidence that it was not apparent on an ordinary inspection.
  3. Assess its seriousness and its impact on the use and value of the home.
  4. Quantify the cost of repair.
  5. Provide objective technical evidence in negotiation or before a court.

How to act

  1. Document the defect (photos, video) without repairing it before the inspection.
  2. Request an expert report as soon as possible: the condition of the defect changes over time.
  3. Notify the seller of the defect in a way that leaves a record (e.g. burofax), without undue delay.
  4. Consult a lawyer on the route of claim and the deadlines that apply.

Outside Catalonia

For a general explanation of what a hidden defect in a home is and how to claim outside Catalonia, see the Kredenis guide to hidden defects in homes (in Spanish).

Have you found a serious defect after buying your home in Catalonia? See our hidden defects expert service in Barcelona or contact us to assess your case.

§ Keep reading

Related notes

View all
§ Consultation

Free initial
consultation

We assess whether your case has expert witness potential. Response within 24 business hours, no commitment.

← Blog
Call Send email